| Platinum | A and B Pizza |
| Gold | A & B Pizza - North Bismarck |
| Silver | Fireflour Pizza |
| Bronze | Bruno's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Amici Pizza |
| Top Pick | Black Lions |
| Top Pick | Nardello's Pizza |
| Top Pick | New York to Go |
| Top Pick | Pizza Ranch |
| Top Pick | The CraftCade - Pizza & Craft Beer Arcade |